🗓️ On this day in history: August 6, 1608
📍 Garrett Island, Mouth of the Susquehanna River
Over four centuries ago, the stillness of the Susquehanna River near its mouth was broken by the rhythmic splash of oars and the creak of wooden timbers. Captain John Smith, English explorer and soldier of fortune, had departed Jamestown, Virginia, on July 24, 1608, with a mission: to chart the upper Chesapeake Bay and its tributaries—including the mighty Susquehanna.
After weeks of exploration and hardship, Smith’s shallow-draft boat was no match for the Susquehanna’s shoals and currents. Forced to halt, he marked the spot on his now-famous map with an “X” and labeled it “Smith Fales.” But his journey wasn’t over. What followed was one of the earliest recorded encounters between English explorers and the Susquehannock people—an Indigenous nation that dominated the river valley for generations.
A Journey to the Edge of a New World
Smith’s 1608 expedition covered nearly 3,000 miles of waterways. At a time when most of the continent was still a mystery to Europeans, Smith’s meticulous observations would later form the basis for the 1612 map of Virginia—arguably one of the most important cartographic achievements of early American history. Engraved by William Hole, it remained the definitive map of the region for over 60 years.
Unlike most modern maps, Smith’s was oriented with west at the top—a reflection of how the English approached the New World by sea. His detailed notations included the location of native towns, tribal territories, rivers, and important encounters—including the “Smith Fales” mark that symbolized both the end of his voyage up the Susquehanna and the beginning of a remarkable meeting.
Meeting the Susquehannocks
With their ship stranded and the Susquehanna River unnavigable, Smith dispatched Native American interpreters overland to request a meeting. It took two days for the message to reach its destination, and the Susquehannocks’ reply was swift and significant.
On August 6, 1608, a delegation of sixty Susquehannock warriors arrived at what is now Garrett Island. What Smith and his men saw left them speechless.
“Such great and well-proportioned men are seldom seen,” Smith later wrote, “for they seemed like giants to the English.”
And to him, they were. While Smith himself stood just 5 foot 3 inches tall, many Susquehannock men averaged six feet or more—broad-shouldered, powerfully built, and clad in deerskins. Their faces were adorned with war paint, and their bodies bore tattoos, jewelry, and symbols of their warrior culture. To Smith and his crew, these were not just men—they were legends walking in the flesh.
Lords of the River
By the time of Smith’s arrival, the Susquehannocks had established themselves as the dominant power in the lower Susquehanna Valley. Since around 1550, they had lived in fortified towns along the river, farming the fertile lands of what is now Lancaster County and fishing the river’s abundant waters. Their longhouses, fields of corn, and strategic palisades formed the backbone of an organized, resilient society.
They were also seasoned traders. Through contact with French and Spanish fishermen along the Atlantic, the Susquehannocks had acquired European goods—glass beads, metal tools, and brass ornaments—which they exchanged with neighboring tribes across the Chesapeake watershed. Smith noted these foreign trinkets during the encounter, proof that the Susquehannocks were no strangers to the expanding world of transatlantic trade.
But this meeting on August 6 marked the beginning of something different. This wasn’t trade from afar—it was face-to-face contact with English colonists who, unbeknownst to either party, would forever alter the course of the region’s history.
An Exchange of Gifts—and Warnings
According to Smith’s account, the Susquehannocks brought with them gifts of tobacco and food, symbols of peace and welcome. They spoke through interpreters, asking about the English, their intentions, and their homeland across the sea. The meeting was respectful but cautious. Both groups understood that the future was shifting.
Smith carefully recorded what he saw, not just their physical appearance but their language, customs, and weapons. He described their bows as longer than those of other tribes he had encountered, and their fortifications as more elaborate. He admired their discipline and structure.
But beneath the diplomacy was a growing tension. While the Susquehannocks ruled the Susquehanna, they were already under pressure from enemies to the north and west. European expansion—still in its infancy—would soon become a tidal wave that no alliance or war club could withstand.
A Moment Frozen in Time
Today, this meeting feels like something from myth—a moment when two worlds touched on the edge of a river. The Susquehannocks, towering and dignified, meeting a band of English explorers from a fledgling colony hundreds of miles to the south.
What they could not have known was that this brief encounter—marked with an “X” on a map and etched in Smith’s journals—would become one of the few surviving records of a thriving civilization destined to vanish within a century. The Susquehannocks, later known as the Conestoga, were devastated by war, disease, and colonization. Their tragic story ended in December 1763, when the last of their people were brutally massacred in Lancaster by a group of vigilantes known as the Paxton Boys—an event that stands as one of the darkest chapters in Pennsylvania’s colonial history.
Still, their legacy endures in the name Susquehanna, in the fertile valleys of Lancaster County, and in the stories we uncover—like this one—more than 400 years later.
Never Miss a New Post
Never miss a new post or article by signing up for email updates below and following Uncharted Lancaster on Facebook or Instagram.