Terror in the Tunnel: A Shenks Ferry Ghost Encounter

Nestled between the winding Susquehanna River and the wooded hollows of southern Lancaster County lies Shenks Ferry, a quiet, almost forgotten stretch of road near Safe Harbor. But ask any local teenager, and you’ll hear it whispered in tones of excitement and dread. The Shenks Ferry Tunnel is more than a shortcut through a wooded ravine—it’s a backroad path to Pequea for those daring (or crazy) enough to drive along the old road that parallels the tracks.

Legends speak of a woman in white—a restless bride, left at the altar, who hanged herself from the tunnel’s stone arch in a final act of despair. Others say she was murdered by a jealous lover or betrayed by the man she loved. Some believe it’s not her ghost that haunts the tunnel, but his—a vengeful spirit struck down by violence in the very spot where young thrill-seekers now gather.

To summon her spirit, brave souls must follow a precise ritual. Drive into the tunnel late at night—closer to midnight, the better. Park in the middle. Shut off the engine. Place your keys on the roof. Then circle the car three times in the dark silence of the tunnel. If done correctly, the ghostly woman sometimes appears—often seen hanging from the stone archway or drifting along the edge of the woods, her white dress faintly glowing in the gloom.

For the then 17-year-old Brynn, who lives in Conestoga Township, this eerie local tradition has become something of a pastime. She and her friends make late-night trips down to the tunnel on a regular basis, daring each other to complete the summoning ritual.

But one visit in mid-February 2024 stands out above all the rest.

It was a chilly Sunday night, just past 8 o’clock. Brynn and three friends, packed into a small car, descended to the tunnel along the desolate Green Hill Road. The usual excitement buzzed among them as they followed the familiar steps—turning off the engine, lights out, keys placed on the roof. They sat quietly in the stillness, waiting, the occasional giggle betraying their nerves.

Then came the faint but undeniable sound. Screee-eee-eeeak. A slow, squeaking noise… like fingers dragging across glass.

Everyone froze!

Eyes darted around the darkened car. One friend in the front seat, trying to break the tension, opened his door for just a second, then slammed it shut. That’s when things took a turn.

The boy seated beside Brynn in the back suddenly panicked. His window had rolled halfway down on its own. No one had touched the controls. In a frenzy, the group screamed for the driver to start the car.

She turned the key. The engine sputtered. Again—nothing but stuttering and silence. For a brief, terrifying moment, they were trapped.

Finally, the engine turned over. Tires screeched as they peeled out of the tunnel, adrenaline pumping.

Later, they would try to rationalize it. Faulty wiring? A coincidence?

But Brynn and her friends aren’t so sure.

Was it the White Angel of Shenks Ferry making her presence known? Or just a car acting up at the worst possible moment?

They’ve been back since—many times. But no other trip has matched the fear and thrill of that night.

And while Shenks Ferry continues to draw in daring locals with its legends of flickering lights in the woods, sulfur smells, ghostly handprints, and cars that refuse to start, one truth remains constant: something waits in the dark down there.

Dare to find out what?

However, this wasn’t Brynn’s only eerie encounter. Click here to read about another chilling experience she had at Chickies Rock—a location that, much like Shenks Ferry, seems to be a hotbed of supernatural activity.

---

Never Miss a New Post

Never miss a new article by signing up for email updates. Follow Uncharted Lancaster on Facebook or Instagram for additional exclusive content.

---