Tales of the Macabre: Lancaster Woman Becomes Pillar of Fire

Woman Becomes Pillar of Fire from Candle. That was the chilling headline splashed across the Lancaster Intelligencer Journal on May 11, 1921. Beneath those words lay the heartbreaking story of 40-year-old Elsie M. Gable—a woman who, in the span of a few terrible seconds, became the victim of a harrowing domestic accident.

It happened the night before, on May 10, at 420 West Walnut Street. Today, the Chestnut Hill home is a picture of modern elegance and historic charm, boasting marble floors, exposed brick, and Viking appliances. But a century ago, the home’s cellar staircase bore silent witness to a horror that would end in tragedy.

Elsie Gable, an invalid for the past decade, stood at the top of the basement steps as her sister, Mrs. Samuel Benfer, returned from below, carrying a candle. Precisely how it happened remains uncertain, but in an instant, the flame found Elsie’s dress. Perhaps a brush of fabric, a stray movement, or an errant draft—whatever the cause, the result was devastating. The fire spread with alarming speed, and before anyone could react, Elsie was engulfed in flames.

Her sister screamed. Her brother-in-law, Samuel Benfer, rushed from the upstairs bedroom, throwing a covering over Elsie and rolling her on the floor in a desperate attempt to smother the flames. It was too late. Most of her clothing had already burned away. Though she was spared internal injuries—having not inhaled the fire—her body was scorched from shoulders to feet.

Dr. E. Snyder arrived quickly to tend to her, but the prognosis was grim. The trauma was severe, and for someone already in frail health, the outlook was bleak. For twelve agonizing days, Elsie lingered in critical condition. On Sunday, May 22, 1921, she succumbed to her injuries.

Elsie was one of several children born to Mrs. Hannah Gable. The family had long resided at 420 West Walnut, and for years, Elsie’s illness had confined her largely to the home. Her tragic death cast a pall over the neighborhood and made headlines across Lancaster County.

Some whispered afterward that Elsie had long been a burden—her care a quiet strain on the household. Though no accusations were ever made, the circumstances of the fire left room for unsettling speculation.

Today, the house stands transformed. Built in 1880, the 2,114-square-foot home has been meticulously updated complete with a grand staircase in the foyer. The home’s stunning interior bears no trace of soot or sorrow—only quiet opulence. Upstairs, a primary suite with a soaking tub and private balcony offers modern luxury undreamed of in Elsie’s time.

Yet for all its beauty, this Walnut Street residence holds a deeper, more somber story within its walls. Behind the exposed brick and beneath the marble floors lies the memory of a woman whose final moments were both tragic and unforgettable.

Today, 420 West Walnut is filled with light and life. But its walls still whisper the tale of Elsie Gable—a reminder that even the most beautiful homes hold tragic stories within.

.

Read More

Read this story and more in my first full-length book, Uncharted Lancaster’s Ghosts, Monsters, and Tales of Adventure. This 283-page book is packed with 64 unforgettable stories, all set right here in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania.

---

Never Miss a New Post

Never miss a new article by signing up for email updates below. Be sure to follow Uncharted Lancaster on Facebook or Instagram for additional exclusive content.

---

Resources

• Lancaster Daily Intelligencer Wed, May 11, 1921 ·Page 1
• Lancaster New Era Wed, May 11, 1921 ·Page 1
• The News-Journal Mon, May 23, 1921 ·Page 1
• 420 W Walnut St Lancaster, PA 17603