Wyngate Manor: A Hidden Castle in Lancaster with a Curious Conservation Twist

While Lancaster County draws its name from the English city of Lancaster in the county of Lancashire—homeland of early settler and county founder John Wright—few expect to find a literal castle nestled in its rolling hills. Yet hidden behind a long, winding, tree-lined driveway off 80 School House Road in Lancaster Township stands a breathtaking English-style estate that feels more at home in the Cotswolds than the Pennsylvania countryside.

Welcome to Wyngate Manor—Lancaster County’s own fairytale castle.

The Hidden Gem of School House Road

From the roadside, there’s little to suggest what lies beyond the long, winding driveway and dense tree cover. A simple sign warns: “Private Property. No trespassing. No turnaround. Beware of dog.” But venture up the elegant drive, and you’ll find a 10-bedroom, 10-bathroom, 11,000-square-foot marvel inspired by England’s great estates.

Originally constructed in 1973 by the late Dr. Charles R. Winter, Wyngate Manor was envisioned as something far greater than a private residence. Born in Magdeburg, Germany, Winter immigrated to the United States and became a renowned orthopedic surgeon in Lancaster County. Over his 45-year career, he served as Chief of Orthopedic Surgery at St. Joseph Hospital and operated both the Winter Orthopedic Clinic and Colonial Hall Rehabilitation Center on Rider Avenue. His pioneering work drew national attention, including the reattachment of a severed arm in 1963 and the fitting of one of the nation’s first Myo-Electric prosthetic arms in 1970.

But Dr. Winter was more than a physician—he was a conservationist, philanthropist, and visionary. From 1972 to 1991, he served on the board of the Lancaster Conservancy, championing efforts to preserve open space and natural landscapes. With its English manor-inspired architecture and 12 acres of serene woodland, Wyngate Manor was central to that mission. Winter dreamed of opening the estate for public benefit, stating in a 1992 interview, “Eventually, I want to donate it to the people of Lancaster.”

That vision was formalized in a conservation easement that legally bound the property to the oversight of the Lancaster Conservancy, intended to protect its natural beauty and limit its development. However, this well-intentioned dream now presents one of the more unusual real estate scenarios in the county. While the easement ensures long-term environmental stewardship, it also raises important questions for future owners about public access and land use—issues that remain unresolved to this day.

Dr. Winter’s community legacy extended beyond the estate. He made a substantial donation to Millersville University, helping establish the Winter Visual and Performing Arts Center, blending his appreciation for science, nature, and the arts into a lasting contribution for future generations.

A Castle Fit for Royalty

From the moment you step inside Wyngate Manor, it’s clear that this was no ordinary family home.

Marble floors modeled after those in England’s Hatfield House, detailed plaster ceilings, French leaded glass, coffered wood ceilings, and stained glass windows evoke Tudor-era splendor. The Great Hall—complete with a towering fireplace, Minstrel Gallery inspired by Berkeley Castle, and floor-to-ceiling windows—serves as the architectural heart of the home.

Other highlights include:

• A private elevator servicing all four floors
• A gourmet kitchen with exposed beams and custom cabinetry
• Ten bedrooms and multiple entertaining spaces, including a rustic dining room with brick floors and a finished lower level with a bar and fitness area
• An outdoor resort-like setting with a swimming pool, pool house, tennis court, pond, and lush landscaping
• Additional buildings, including a six-car garage with a rented apartment above and a second home at 100 School House Road

In total, the estate spans over 12 acres—a serene and private retreat, steeped in historic architectural charm.

The Conservation Catch

Wyngate Manor’s grandeur comes with strings attached.

The conservation easement placed on the property in 1992 grants the Lancaster Conservancy long-term stewardship. Under this agreement, the land must be maintained in its natural state. Trees can’t be removed without permission, and no significant structural changes can be made without the Conservancy’s blessing. Perhaps most intriguingly, the easement allows for potential limited public access, including educational events, nature studies, and even public tours, should the property owner and Conservancy reach an agreement.

While the Conservancy has not had contact with the Winter family in over a decade, they continue to monitor the property and would be involved in any future developments. The easement also states that the Conservancy may one day use existing buildings for offices or an educational center, though no such plans are currently in place.

A Dream Deferred?

The Winter children, who inherited the property following the passing of their parents, are now selling the estate. Listed by Anne Lusk of Lusk & Associates Sotheby’s International Realty, Wyngate Manor hit the market for $2.5 million.

However, potential buyers must grapple with the implications of the conservation easement. While the listing refers to the property as a private estate, legal language still reflects Dr. Winter’s original vision of public benefit.

As attorney Dwight Yoder noted in a 2022 interview, would-be homeowners may wish to seek clarification—or even judicial guidance—before committing to the purchase.

A Storybook Ending?

Whether Wyngate Manor will remain a private castle hidden in the hills or fulfill its original destiny as a public treasure remains to be seen. For now, it stands as one of Lancaster County’s most unique architectural landmarks—a grand estate with a foot in the past, a nod to conservation, and an uncertain future.

So… anyone want to go halves on a $2.5 million English manor? We’ll even flip a coin for who gets the Minstrel Gallery. For more information about the property, visit the Zillow listing.

---

Never Miss a New Post

Never miss a new article by signing up for email updates. Follow Uncharted Lancaster on Facebook or Instagram for additional exclusive content.

---

Resources

• 80 School House Rd, Lancaster, PA 17603
• Charles R. Winter
• Questions about public use remain as Wyngate Manor in Lancaster Township is put up for sale