Exploring the Haunted Depths of the Columbia Market House Dungeon

Nestled in the heart of history-rich Columbia, Pennsylvania, lies a location steeped in dark lore and intriguing paranormal activity—the Columbia Market House dungeon. This enigmatic site, with its haunting past, has become a focal point for those fascinated by the supernatural.

Chris Vera, a name synonymous with the preservation of Columbia’s history, is the president of the Columbia Historic Preservation Society, the chair of the Zion Hill Cemetery restoration project, and the manager of the Columbia Market House. His deep involvement with the dungeon has led to personal encounters with the unexplainable, lending credibility to the ghostly legends that surround this place.

One chilling experience shared by Vera involved a sinister manifestation in the dungeon. He and his brother witnessed a terrifying phenomenon — a black mass that seemed to defy the laws of nature, crawling up the wall and stretching across the ceiling. This dark, amorphous entity then began to advance down the hallway towards them, its intent unknown. The encounter was so intense that it sent Vera and his brother fleeing upstairs, seeking refuge from the unnerving presence.

The dungeon’s spectral residents are not limited to nameless shadows. One of the most frequently mentioned ghosts is Andrew, who is said to eternally pace through the dungeon walls, perhaps a reflection of his restless spirit. The nature of his existence and the story behind his haunting remain shrouded in mystery, adding to the dungeon’s enigmatic aura.

Another ghostly inhabitant identified by a local psychic is known as “Big John.” Legend has it that “Big John” met a tragic and violent end within these very walls, murdered in his cell by unknown assailants. His spirit is said to linger in the dungeon, perpetually searching for those responsible for his demise. The story of “Big John” adds a layer of tragic intrigue to the already chilling atmosphere of the dungeon.

Phantom specters aren’t limited to the market house’s dungeon. Numerous times, the ghost of a little girl who wanders the alley has been spotted. If you try to approach her, the shy apparition quickly disappears around a corner. Click here to read more.

For paranormal enthusiasts and history buffs alike, the Columbia Market House dungeon offers a unique glimpse into the intersection of history and the supernatural. The experiences of Chris Vera and others serve as a bridge between the past and the present, allowing us to explore the mysteries of what lies beyond. These ghostly tales remind us that some aspects of history refuse to be forgotten, echoing through the corridors of time in the most unexpected ways.

Legends of Lancaster

Planning Your Trip

Columbia Market House is a vital center for fresh produce, specialty foods, and community experience. Established in 1869 to connect citizens and farmers, the Market has returned with a year-round farmers market, restaurant, and event space. It is home to a large array of delishish fresh-made meals, farm fresh produce, baked goods, meats, candy, and crafts. The market is open Saturdays from 7 am to 3 pm. The Columbia Market House is located at 15 S. Third St., Columbia, PA 17512. Click here to visit their website.

---

Adventure Awaits!

Never miss a new post or article by signing up for email updates below and following Uncharted Lancaster on Facebook or Instagram.

---

Resources

• Columbia Market House
• John L. Sullivan
• Legends of Lancaster: Exploring the Columbia Market House Dungeon
• Columbia Market House Lockup
• Columbia Market House Market House with local vendors
• Lancaster New Era 24 Jan 1894, Wed ·Page 4
• LancasterHistory
• Dungeons Beneath the Market House

---

Haunted Lancaster: The sad tale of Lover’s Leap at Chickies Rock

Even if you don’t believe in ghosts or spectral apparitions, Chickies Rock is a place of death. At least 13 people have died there since 1981. The earliest deaths involved a Native American murder-suicide love triangle. Click here to read more.

The Witch Sisters’ Chiquesalunga Curse at Chickies Rock

Three witch sisters once lived in a small house atop Chiques Hill. Rather than leave their land when forced out by the Columbia & Donegal Electric Railway, these witches committed suicide, but not before putting an evil curse on the property. Some believe the ground is still cursed today. Click here to read more.