Join the search for Lancaster County’s oldest tombstone

The question is simple. Where is Lancaster County’s oldest tombstone located? A safe bet would be somewhere near Willow Street or Lampeter.

Extra Credit Question: Was the town of Lampeter named after handicapped tavern keeper Peter Yeordya?

It was here in 1710 that the first settlement in what would eventually become Lancaster County (1729) was established. In fact, the County’s oldest surviving dwelling, the Hans Herr House built in 1719 by Christian and Anna Herr, is just a few miles outside of Willow Street. You can still visit it today.

Tschantz Graveyard 1733

TschantzCemetery1

The closest, oldest cemetery is about two miles away. The Tschantz Graveyard dates back to 1733 and is believed to contain the graves of three of these 1710 pioneers: Wendel Bauman (Bowman), Martin Meylin, and Jacob Miller.

The oldest surviving legible tombstone belongs to Miller. He died on April 20, 1739. The English translation of the German script on his tombstone stone reads:

1742. Here lies buried the old Jacob Miller. Born in Germany. He died Apri 20, 1739. When he died, his age was 76 years, 1 month and 3 weeks.

img_6039
Jacob Miller’s tombstone. Some historians believe there was an epidemic in the settlement between 1739 and 1742; thus, the stone cutter made four stones in 1742 even though some deaths were earlier.

Despite the community being laid out in 1710 and the nearby Tschantz Cemetery being founded in 1733, 14 older tombstones exist elsewhere in Lancaster County. To find them, you have to travel 13 miles south to Chestnut Level Presbyterian Church Graveyard in Drumore Township. Click here to read more about Tschantz Cemetery.

Chestnut Level Cemetery

Interestingly enough, there are two Chestnut Level Cemeteries—old and new. My initial research indicated the winner of the County’s oldest tombstone was in the “new” Chestnut Level Cemetery at 1068 Chestnut Level Rd, Quarryville, PA 17566. Click here for directions.

Screenshot 2020-03-23 at 11.15.53 AM
“New” Chestnut Level Cemetery

The grave in question belongs to Elizabeth King, who died February 21, 1732, at the age of 23. Her stone reads, “Here lyeth th(e) body of Elizabeth King who departed this life 21 day of Febu’y 1732 Aged 23.” Hand-carved flowers adorn the top of her stone.

Screenshot 2020-03-23 at 11.18.04 AM
Elizabeth King’s 1732 gravestone.

She is buried next to her husband, Robert King, who didn’t die until 1763. To locate Elizabeth King’s grave, walk through the main gate of the cemetery. It will be on your left about ten stones in three rows back. The pin on the map below marks the grave’s exact location.

With the answer found and photographs taken, I was just about ready to publish this article. But in the process of doing some additional background research on the cemeteries at Chestnut Level, I found an older headstone existed. According to the Chestnut Level Presbyterian Church website, “The first burial (based upon a readable monument) was in 1726.”

So I grabbed my camera and made my second 25-minute commute to “old” Chestnut Level Cemetery.

“Old” Chestnut Level Cemetery 1725

“Old” Chestnut Level Cemetery is located on the corner of River Road and Slate Hill Road in Drumore Township. It is enclosed by a three to four foot high stone wall with a thick slate top. The cornerstone on the gate’s left reads, “Chestnut Level Cemetery Founded  1725,” which makes it eight years older than Tschantz Cemetery. On the gate’s right, the words “Wall Rebuilt 1905” are inscribed. Click here for the exact location.

Screenshot 2020-03-23 at 11.22.40 AM
Chestnut Level Cemetery Founded 1725

An inventory of the cemetery in 1935 “found 287 tombstones – 98 slate, 172 marble and sandstone, and 17 of the large flat kind.” They claimed that there were more slate markers in this cemetery than in any other that they had visited. Slate has a distinct advance over sandstone or limestone tombstones as it better preserves the engravings.

rowOfStones
A row of slate graves in old Chestnut Level Cemetery.

During my first trip, I had wandered through searching for Elizabeth King’s 1732 tombstone, unsure of its exact location. I photographed several graves from the early 1700s. Below is John Midlton, who died on September 9, 1739 (but still younger than Jacob Miller’s April 1739 Tschantz Cemetery tombstone).

Screenshot 2020-03-23 at 11.24.05 AM
John Midlton’s 1739 gravestone.

A short distance away is Izabela Moore. She was born in 1665 and died on December 17, 1732. Moore’s grave is about ten months younger than King’s.

IMG_1345
Izabela Moore’s 1732 headstone.

Lancaster County’s Oldest Tombstone?

Elizabeth Shaw McPherson possibly claims Lancaster’s oldest headstone. She died on December 17, 1726, at the age of 36. That beats King by six years. Elizabeth is buried with her husband, William McPherson. The couple also shares a tombstone—and here’s the caveat—William didn’t die until October 5, 1783. That’s 51 years after King. You could definitely make the argument that the joint stone replaced Elizabeth McPherson’s original 1726 stone. If that’s the case, then Elizabeth King has the oldest.

What do you think?

ElizabethMcPherson
Elizabeth Shaw McPherson 1726

To locate Elizabeth McPherson’s grave, walk through the iron gate at the “Old” Chestnut Level Cemetery. It will be on your right in the first row three stones in. The pin on the map below marks her grave’s exact location.

Postscript

Could there be older tombstones in Lancaster County? Absolutely. However, it is unlikely they are the original stone (similar to Elizabeth McPherson) or is merely illegible after almost 300 years. If you know of one older, let me know.

Planning Your Visit

Both cemeteries are open to the public from dawn to dusk. If you do visit, keep in mind that you are in a cemetery and should conduct yourself in an appropriate, respectful manner.

Gallery

Resources

One thought on “Join the search for Lancaster County’s oldest tombstone

  1. Have you checked out the Little Britain Presbyterian or “old LB” cemeteries? Also the many Quaker cemeteries?

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: